|
A
Cure for AIDS by 2010 ... "at the Latest"
Martin
Delaneythe man who may be in the best
position to bring about that hopeful scenariois
coming to Houston
by
Paul Simmons
|
 |
For
most Americans, the red, angry scowl of playwright
Larry Kramer is the public face of AIDS activism.
Even though Kramer long ago retired from the work,
his hostile, controversial style left an indelible
impression.
But
for Americans living with HIV/AIDS, another figure
is better known and arguably more important: former
Jesuit seminarian Martin Delaney. If Kramer is
the Darth Vader of AIDS advocacy, Delaney is the
chief of its Jedi council.
Delaney
is founding director of San Franciscos Project
Inform, the nations most influential HIV
treatment information and advocacy organization.
Although half a dozen other groups nationwide
do similar work, with a staff of 25 and annual
contributions of more than $2 million, Project
Inform is the powerhouse. (By contrast, the Center
for AIDS in Houston, the flagship treatment advocacy
organization in the southern United States, has
a staff of five and annual receipts of slightly
less than $500,000.)
While
well briefed on the particulars of AIDS research
and clinical carehe sits on the federal
panel that issues treatment guidelinesDelaney
generally eschews the detailed policy work efforts
pursued by other activists; instead, he focuses
on painting a broad vision of the future, coloring
it with sunny California optimism. In a January
2001 essay for POZ magazine, he declared
flatly that science would produce a "functional
cure" for HIV by 2010"at the very
latest." At public presentations, he delivers
the same message with a full-throated buoyancy
that connects readily with HIVers.
The
Annual Retrovirus Conferencewhich convened
in Chicago this past Februaryis the largest
meeting of AIDS researchers in the United States.
At the 2001 conference, federal authorities backed
off from their treatment mantra of "hit hard,
hit early" that had pushed almost every HIVer
into anti-HIV drug therapy. (In addition to their
high costs, anti-HIV drugs are inconvenient and
toxic.) The new recommendation is for infected
people to wait until the CD4 count, an important
measure of immune function, has dropped to 350
before starting a treatment regimen. Delaney calls
this one of the most important recent developments
in AIDS, saying this new approach is a rejection
of the "sink and drain" model of therapy.
Also
at this years conference, Anthony Fauci,
M.D., the federal governments top AIDS researcher,
presented early information on a one-week-on,
one-week-off treatment plan. Using data from a
small study, Fauci showed how it might be possible
for HIVers to cut their time on drugs in half.
"I find that very intriguing," Delaney
says. If Faucis experiment pans out in the
long run, "its a major finding."
But Delaney holds out for something even more
startling for his functional cure: "I think
it needs to go even further than that. Ideally,
Id like us to get to the place where you
could take people off treatment and leave them
off it." It may be, Delaney says, that Faucis
approach is the "best you can do. But Im
jazzed on the notion of ... viral control without
drugs."
An
integral component of that notion is interleukin-2
(IL-2), an immune booster. Researchers, including
some in Houston, are now investigating IL-2 in
two large studies. But those studies will take
several years to complete, and some people are
anxious to have IL-2 on the market sooner. The
U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) routinely
grants accelerated, or early, approval to anti-HIV
drugs. But theres no precedent for giving
early approval to immune boosters for people with
HIV, and its unclear if the FDA will make
an exception for IL-2. But Delaney would. "In
terms of accelerated licensure, I think they [the
makers of IL-2] have got as good data as weve
seen from some other drugs. The only downside
of IL-2 use, obviously, is the side effects during
those days the person takes it. Beyond that, I
think the case is inarguable that it produces
genuine, lasting improvements in CD4 ... well
beyond what we get with antivirals alone."
His
comments mark the first time a U.S. AIDS activist
has publicly declared support for the early approval
of IL-2, which may put him at odds with advocates
who want to wait until the studies are complete.
But Delaney counters: "Why is it that only
people with the right insurance or a clever doctor
[have access to IL-2]? . . . Why isnt it
more widely available?"
If
many people with HIV lack the right insurance,
it may be because the demographics of the epidemic
have changed sharply in the last several years.
What was once a disease almost exclusively associated
in the public mind with gay white men has now
spread to include significant numbers of black
heterosexuals. Yet high-powered treatment activism
remains largely the province of Anglo gay males.
"Well," Delaney says, "the activists
that are there arent just going to disappear
and go away, so maybe that makes it a little harder
for new people to break in. But the obstacle [to
more minority activists] is that their own agencies
dont support them to do this kind of work.
So to bring more people of color in as activists,
youre going to have to see a change of heart
on behalf of their agencies, and youre going
to have to see a willingness on our part to act
as mentors to bring them on board."
Although
not a minority, one new player already on board
is George W. Bush, winner of a close and contested
November presidential election. Delaney suggests,
tentatively, that HIVers may have less to fear
from Bush than previously thought. "This
guy is an enigma so far. He says one thing, but
he tends to be doing things that are more favorable,
or look more favorable, than weve expected
so far. It seems like hes getting the conservatives
more angry than he is us. If thats the case,
Im not nearly as worried as I thought Id
be." In a recent address to Congress, President
Bush reaffirmed his support for doubling the budget
of the National Institutes of Health, which is
the federal agency responsible for federal research
on AIDS.
Houstons
HIV-infected population includes a large segment
with advanced disease and few remaining treatment
options. But Delaneys optimism covers them,
too. "Dont be so sure youre left
behind. We were writing people off for dead in
1996, but theyre still with us."
Delaneys
brand of treatment and policy optimism will be
on display in Houston at a community workshop
hosted by the Center for AIDS on Wednesday, April
18, at the Houston Museum of Health and Medical
Science, 1515 Hermann Dr. A light buffet reception
begins at 6:30 p.m., with a treatment update from
Delaney at 7 p.m. Free and open to the public.
Paul
Simmons, a registered nurse certified in HIV/AIDS
nursing, is director of treatment information
and advocacy at the Center for AIDS. He also chairs
the Houston advisory board for the Community Programs
for Clinical Research on AIDS, a federal program
for HIV research. His e-mail address is paul@centerforaids.org.
If
you have any comments about this article, please
email them to letters@outsmartmagazine.com.
|